The Legendary Central Grocery Muffuletta: A New Orleans Tradition Worth the Hype
If you’ve ever wandered down Decatur Street in the French Quarter of New Orleans, you’ve probably noticed a long line snaking out of a humble Italian grocery with an old-fashioned sign that simply reads: Central Grocery & Deli. No flashing lights, no trendy décor, just the scent of vinegar, olives, and crusty bread that pulls you in like a magnet. That’s the birthplace of the iconic Muffuletta Sandwich — a sandwich so famous it has become as synonymous with New Orleans cuisine as gumbo, jambalaya, and beignets.
The muffuletta (pronounced muff-uh-LET-tuh, though locals often say muff-uh-LOT-tuh) is no ordinary sandwich. It’s a 10-inch round sesame loaf sliced horizontally and stacked with layers of Genoa salami, mortadella, capicola or ham, provolone, mozzarella, and—here’s the game-changer—Central Grocery’s zesty olive salad. This isn’t just a condiment; it’s a briny, garlicky, herb-infused masterpiece of chopped olives, giardiniera, roasted peppers, capers, and vinegar-spiked olive oil that seeps into the bread, marrying everything together.
A Sandwich Born of Sicilian Ingenuity
The story goes back to 1906 when Sicilian immigrants in New Orleans wanted a hearty lunch that could feed dock workers and market vendors without falling apart. Salvatore Lupo, the owner of Central Grocery, layered up the meats, cheeses, and olive relish on a big round loaf. The name “muffuletta” came from the Sicilian sesame bread itself. The sandwich was meant to be portable, affordable, and satisfying. Instead, it became a full-blown New Orleans legend.
Over a century later, the muffuletta remains one of the most beloved New Orleans food traditions. While po’boys and oysters may battle for the spotlight, the muffuletta is the sandwich locals recommend to anyone visiting the Crescent City for the first time.
A Ritual at Central Grocery
There’s something special about grabbing a muffuletta at Central Grocery. The line moves fast; the sandwiches are pre-made in giant stacks behind the counter, wrapped in white paper, waiting to be devoured. Locals know it’s best eaten on a bench along the Mississippi River, unwrapped like a gift, and shared with friends.
True devotees swear by letting the sandwich rest for a few hours to let the flavors soak into the bread. Even Central Grocery advises you don’t need to heat it — the magic happens at room temperature.
Bringing the French Quarter Home
At Restaurant Recipe Recreations, we set out to recreate Central Grocery’s Muffuletta Sandwich in your own kitchen. Our copycat recipe starts with that all-important olive salad made a day ahead so the vinegar and herbs work their way deep into every olive and pepper. Use a good round sesame loaf that’s slightly dense but tender, so it can hold all that juicy filling without getting soggy.
This isn’t just a sandwich; it’s a flavor-packed edible postcard from New Orleans.
Why the Muffuletta Still Rules
What makes the muffuletta so enduring? It’s the perfect balance of salty, tangy, rich, and hearty. It’s a crowd-pleaser that can be made ahead and sliced into wedges for parties, picnics, or game day. And it’s part of the culinary heritage of the Crescent City, a sandwich that tells a story of immigrants, tradition, and flavor.
Plan Your Own Muffuletta Tradition
Next time you visit New Orleans, don’t just grab a beignet at Café du Monde — make a beeline for Central Grocery’s original muffuletta sandwich. And when you can’t hop a flight, bring the taste of the French Quarter to your kitchen with our authentic Central Grocery-style Muffuletta recipe.
For more New Orleans inspired recipes, try Pappadeaux’s Gumbo and Cheesecake Factory’s Cajun Jambalaya Pasta
Ingredients
- For the Olive Salad (make a day ahead if possible):
- 2 cups mixed green and kalamata olives, pitted and roughly chopped
- ½ cup pickled vegetables (giardiniera), chopped
- 2 cloves garlic, minced
- 2 tablespoons capers
- ½ teaspoon dried oregano
- ½ teaspoon red pepper flakes (optional)
- ¾ cup olive oil
- ¼ cup red-wine vinegar
- Sandwich:
- 1 large sesame Italian loaf (about 10-inch muffuletta bread or soft round focaccia)
- ¼ lb sliced Genoa salami
- ¼ lb sliced mortadella
- ¼ lb sliced capicola or good ham
- ¼ lb sliced provolone cheese
- ¼ lb sliced mozzarella cheese
Instructions
-
Make the Olive Salad:
Combine all olive-salad ingredients in a mixing bowl. Stir well, cover, and refrigerate at least 4 hours—ideally overnight. -
Prep the Bread:
Slice loaf horizontally. Hollow out a little of the soft interior to make room for filling. Brush both cut sides with a spoonful of the olive-salad marinade. -
Layer the Filling:
Spread half the olive salad over the bottom bread. Add salami, mortadella, capicola/ham, then cheeses. Finish with remaining olive salad. Top with the other bread half. -
Press & Rest:
Wrap tightly in plastic wrap or parchment. Place a heavy pan or cast-iron skillet on top and let rest at least 1 hour at room temperature (or chill up to 24 hours). -
Slice & Serve:
Cut into wedges—about 4-6 servings. Traditionally served at room temperature (not toasted).
Notes
Bread matters: look for a slightly dense but tender sesame round so it holds the juicy filling without getting soggy. Don’t skip the press: it’s the secret to Central Grocery’s iconic texture. Make-ahead magic: the sandwich improves after a few hours as flavors meld.
FULL VIDEO TUTORIAL
